There is another side to the chlorine-water story. When we return from
a gym workout or a jogging session or a game of squash, not only are we
thirsty but we usually shower or bathe. We have been taught that cleanliness
and health go together, and indeed they do, when chemical-free water is
used. When chlorinated water is used, however, bathing may be much less
healthy than we ever supposed.
Gasses are as a rule less soluble in hot water, and when water is heated
or boiled dissolved gasses are released. Boiling water is as we noted
earlier a way in which the free chlorine content in water is greatly reduced,
the chlorine escaping into the air. When we have a hot shower or run a
bath we can sometimes smell the chlorine released as it escapes from the
hot water. In a confined shower recess, however, especially one with poor
ventilation, the chlorine escapes from the water as we continue the hot
shower and steadily increases in concentration in the air we breath.
The olfactory threshold for chlorine is about 3.5PPM (parts per million)
so when we can smell chlorine the concentration is already above this
level. The lethal concentration for ten-minute exposure is about 600 PPM
and we suggest that regularly taking hot showers with chlorinated water
could pose a health risk. Chlorine causes pulmonary edema, and it would
seem likely that regular exposure to chlorine gas even at low levels such
as in normal showering may reduce the oxygen transfer capacity of the
lungs. This could be a critical factor for athletes and for others prone
to heart failure.
Another aspect to be considered is our skin. Our skin is an important
protective barrier for our bodies. When we shower with chlorinated water
we are essentially exposing our skin to a relatively large volume of a
dilute chlorine solution. Some of this chlorine reacts with the oils in
the skin to form chlorinated compounds and it is these compounds which
may then be absorbed by the body. It seems very likely, considering the
strong oxidizing power of chlorine, that regular exposure to chlorinated
water serves also to promote the aging process of the skin, not unlike
extended exposure to sunlight. Moreover, chlorine may actually enhance
the aging effects of ultraviolet radiation by reinforcing the process
of cell deterioration.
Another skin factor to be considered with the destruction by chlorine
of the natural bacteria balance on our skin. Our skin has an ecology,
all of its own, which needs to be preserved in order to maintain healthy
skin and its associated beauty.
Article published by:
Whedon Young Productions Pty. Ltd. 372 Eastern Valley Way, Chatswood, New
South Wales 2067, Australia From "One Hundred Years Of Water Chlorination",
Pages 44-49, by John F. Ashton, Chief Chemist Australian Food Research Laboratories
and by Dr. Ronald S. Laura, Professor in Education, University of Newcastle
and Chairman, Sports Medicine and Health Education Committee, Hunter Academy
of Sport, New South Wales.
REFERENCES
Hodges L., Environmental Pollution, (N.Y. : Holt, Reinhart and
Winston, 2nd Ed., 1977, p. 189).
Llewllyn, W. J., Journal American Medical Association, Vol. 146,
No. 13, 1951, P. 1273.
Sinclair, H.M. (Cited by Clark,L., Get Well Naturally, N.Y.: ARC
Books, 1971, P.327).
Passwater, R.A., Super-Nutrition for Healthy Hearts, N.Y.: Jove
Publications Inc., 1987, pp.155 - 156).
Price, J.M., Coronaries, Cholesterol, Chlorine, Banhadlog Hall,
Tyliwch, Llandridloes: Pyramid Publications Ltd., 1984, pp. 32,33).
"Atherosclerosis may start with cell proliferation" Journal
American Medical Association. Vol. 227,No.7, 1974,p.734).
Revis, N.W., McCauley P., Bull R., and drinking water disinfectants to
plasma cholesterol and thyroid hormone levels in experimental studies,
Proc. National Academy of Science, USA Vol. 83, March 1986, p.
1485. p. 1489.
"Preliminary Assessment of Suspected Carcinogens in Drinking Water'
Report to Congress, US Environmental Protection Agency, Washing D.C.,
1975.
"Water Contaminated Throughout US", Chemical & Eng.
News, 28 April, 1075,p.19.
Dowty, B., Carlisle, D. Laseter, J.L. "Halogenated Hydrocarbons
in New Orleans Drinking Water and Blood Plasma", Science,
Vol. 187, 1975, pp.75-77.
Pate, T., Harris, R.H. Epstein, S.S., "Drinking Water and Cancer
Mortality in Louisiana", Science, Vol. 193, 1976, pp.55-57.
Trehy, M.L. and Bieber, T.I., "Detection, Identification and Quantitative
Analysis of Dihaloacetonitriles in Chlorinated Natural Waters?, in Keith,
L.H., (Ed.) Advances in Identification and Analysis.